Introduction
Endoscopist performance may fluctuate throughout the day, potentially influencing adenoma detection during colonoscopy. Endoscopist fatigue has been proposed as contributing factor but few studies have rigorously examined its impact using precise quality metrics1,2.
Aims & Methods
This study compared corrected withdrawal time (cWT) and lesion detection metrics between morning and afternoon procedures to assess the effect of procedural timing.
We conducted a prospective analysis of elective colonoscopies performed in adult patients (≥18 years) at the University of Montreal Hospital Center by 19 endoscopists. All procedures were video-recorded and annotated in real-time by trained research assistants. Procedures performed solely for polypectomy, those with incomplete examinations, technical failures, or performed by endoscopists with fewer than 10 colonoscopies were excluded. cWT was defined as the withdrawal time minus the duration of all therapeutic interventions. The primary outcome was the comparison of mean cWT between morning and afternoon colonoscopies. Secondary outcomes included the cWT required to reach ADR threshold ≥35%, adenoma detection rate (ADR), advanced ADR (AADR), sessile serrated lesion detection rate (SSLDR), adenomas per colonoscopy (APC), and the per-lesion intervention time, all stratified by time of day. The increase of all performance measures per additional cWT minute were further compared across time of day, adjusting for patient demographics, bowel preparation quality, indication for colonoscopy, computed-assisted detection use, and clustering by individual endoscopist using generalized estimated equations.
Results
A total of 1,437 colonoscopies were included, of which 665 were performed in the morning and 772 in the afternoon. Morning colonoscopies had significantly longer mean cWT than afternoon procedures (8'49'' vs. 8'11''; P=0.002), despite similar per-lesion intervention durations (1’32’’ vs 1’28’’, P=0.425). To achieve an ADR ≥35%, afternoon procedures required on average 1’42’’ more cWT than morning ones (10'02'' vs. 8'20''). Mean ADR and AADR were higher in the morning (ADR: 36.2% vs. 32.4%, P=0.138; AADR: 7.2% vs. 6.5%, P=0.652), although not statistically significant (Table 1). For each additional cWT minute, adenoma detection odds increased by 7.2% in the morning (P=0.003) and 5.9% in the afternoon (P=0.049), suggesting reduced detection efficiency later in the day despite comparable polyp intervention times. Also, the increases in the odds of detecting advanced adenoma dropped from 13.1% in the morning to 7.8% in the afternoon for each additional cWT minute. This reduction was not as steep for SSLDR and APC metrics.
Table 1. Metrics’ estimated summaries overall and by time of day.
| Metrics | Overall
Mean (95% CI) | Morning
Mean (95% CI) | Afternoon
Mean (95% CI) | Overall
Increase/additional cWT minute (p-value) | Morning
Increase/additional cWT minute (p-value) | Afternoon
Increase/additional cWT minute (p-value) |
| ADR | 34.2% (31.7-36.7) | 36.2% (32.6-40.0) | 32.4% (29.1-35.8) | 6.6% (0.003) | 7.2% (0.003) | 5.9% (0.049) |
| AADR | 6.8% (5.6-8.3) | 7.2% (5.4-9.5) | 6.5% (4.9-8.5) | 10.6% (<0.001) | 13.1% (<0.001) | 7.8% (0.100) |
| SSLDR | 4.8% (3.8-6.1) | 4.7% (3.2-6.6) | 4.9% (3.6-6.8) | 12.4% (<0.001) | 13.1% (0.001) | 12.1% (<0.001) |
| APC | 0.6 (0.6-0.7) | 0.7 (0.6-0.8) | 0.6 (0.5-0.7) | 7.4% (<0.001) | 7.4% (<0.001) | 7.3% (<0.001) |
ADR, adenoma detection rate; AADR, advanced adenoma detection rate; SSLDR, sessile serrated lesion detection rate; APC, adenoma per colonoscopy; cWT, corrected withdrawal time.
Conclusion
Colonoscopy outcomes were influenced by procedural timing, with morning examinations associated with higher adenoma detection and more efficient use of WT. Afternoon procedures required longer cWT to achieve comparable detection benchmark of ≥35%, indicating potential performance fatigue. These findings suggest that optimizing endoscopy scheduling may enhance diagnostic yield and overall quality of care.
References
1. Sanaka MR, Deepinder F, Thota PN, Lopez R, Burke CA. Adenomas are detected more often in morning than in afternoon colonoscopy. Am J Gastroenterol. 2009;104(7):1659–1665. doi:10.1038/ajg.2009.188
2. Lee CK, Cha JM, Kim WJ, et al. Endoscopist fatigue may contribute to a decline in the effectiveness of screening colonoscopy. J Clin Gastroenterol. 2015;49(7):e51–e56. doi:10.1097/MCG.0000000000000300
Disclosure
Daniel von Renteln has received research funding from ERBE Elektromedizin GmbH, Ventage, Pendopharm, Fujifilm, and Pentax, and has received consultant or speaker fees from Boston Scientific Inc., ERBE Elektromedizin GmbH, and Pendopharm. Roupen Djinbachian has received speaker fees from Fujifilm. The remaining authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.