Introduction

The optimal surgical approach to reduce recurrence rates after laparoscopic repair of paraesophageal hernia (PEH) is yet to be defined. The crural repair is challenged by both axial and transverse-lateral tension, which may compromise durability. The aim of this double-blind randomized clinical trial was to investigate whether a left-sided diaphragmatic relaxing incision in addition to standard crural repair and fundoplication reduces anatomical recurrence rates at one year postoperatively.

Aims & Methods

This study was conducted at two high-volume Swedish centers—Ersta Hospital (Stockholm) and Sahlgrenska University Hospital (Gothenburg)—between August 2019 and August 2023. Adult patients undergoing surgery for PEH were randomized 1:1 to either standard crural repair with total (360°) fundoplication (control) or the same procedure with the addition of a left-sided diaphragmatic relaxing incision covered by synthetic mesh (intervention). Patients with prior hiatal surgery, ASA class IV or above, type I hernia, major esophageal motility disorders, or any contraindication to fundoplication were excluded. Blinding for patients and assessors was maintained throughout follow-up. Pre- and postoperative assessments included computed tomography (CT), symptom questionnaires (Dakkak dysphagia score, Gastrointestinal Symptom Rating Scale [GSRS]), and quality of life (QoL, RAND-36). The primary outcome was radiologically confirmed PEH recurrence at 12 months.

Results

Of 103 patients screened, 76 were randomized (38 per group). Baseline characteristics were well balanced. CT was completed in 72 patients (95%) at 12 months. The recurrence rate was 66% in the control group and 54% in the intervention group (p=0.313). Three patients in the intervention group had asymptomatic CT verified herniation at the site of the diaphragmatic incision. There were no differences in recurrence size distribution (<4 cm vs >4 cm) between groups. Postoperative symptom assessment revealed significant improvements in dysphagia, reflux, indigestion, and abdominal pain in both groups, without intergroup differences. Physical QoL (PCS) improved significantlywhereas mental QoL (MCS) remained unchanged. Two deaths occurred within 90 days postoperatively (1 per group), yielding a 90-day mortality of 2.6%. Other complications included mediastinal abscess (n=1, intervention group) and need for postoperative endoscopic dilatation (n=5 in total). Operation time tended to be longer in the intervention group (150 vs 133 min; p=ns).

Conclusion

In this randomized, double-blind trial, the addition of a left-sided diaphragmatic relaxing incision to standard laparoscopic PEH repair did not improve anatomical recurrence rates, symptom relief or QoL at 12 months after surgery and should not be recommended for routine use. Alternative strategies to improve recurrence rates after PEH need to be explored in the future.