Introduction
Achalasia is a rare benign esophageal motor disorder characterized by incomplete relaxation of the lower esophageal sphincter (LES). The treatment of achalasia is not curative, but rather is aimed at allowing bolus passage into stomach, reducing LES pressure. Actually in patients without severe comorbidities, surgery should be considered. Myotomy with partial fundoplication has been considered the first-line treatment for non-advanced achalasia. It is commonly performed via laparoscopic approach, however recently, robotic approach seems to provide similar or better results. However, up to date, there is any randomized controlled trial comparing the two mininvasive approach.
Aims & Methods
To compare robotic Heller myotomy and Dor fundoplication (RHD) and laparoscopic Heller myotomy and Dor fundoplication (LHD) regarding their efficacy and outcomes for the treatment of achalasia. The starting protocol will deal only with immediate clinical outcomes. All treatment-naive adult patients who had been diagnosed with achalasia based on clinical and manometric criteria (dysphagia score ≥ II and Eckardt score > 3, Achalasia type I and II sec. Chicago 4.0) were randomized to undergo either LHD or RHD. The outcome measures were anesthesia time, procedure time, symptom improvement, reflux symptoms (as determined with the Gastroesophageal Reflux Disease Questionnaire), the occurrence of adverse events (AEs), length of stay (LOS), and quality of life (QoL). Upper endoscopy, barium column height at 1 and 5 min (on a barium esophagogram), pressure at the LES will be studied during the second study phase.
Results
Eighteen patients were randomized. There were no statistically significant differences between the LHD and RHD groups regarding symptom improvement at 1 mo of follow-up (P = 0.253) as well as for rates of reflux symptoms. There were also no statistical differences regarding the occurrence of AEs, or LOS. Anesthesia time and was significantly shorter in the LHD group than in the RHD group (120.00 ± 16.52 and 93.70 ± 10.41 min; P < 0.001), whereas procedure time (from first instrument movement to last instrument removal) was similar (42.12 ± 11.42 for RHD vs. 45.54 vs 8.42 for LHD, P= 0.542). In both groups, there were improvements in all domains of the QoL questionnaire, and Eckardt score.
Conclusion
RHD and LHD appear to be equally effective in controlling the symptoms of achalasia, and minimizing AEs. Nevertheless, RHD still needs greater anesthesia time for docking and preparation.